CMU Paper Reviewer

Upload your manuscript and get feedback on the five most critical issues to address.

Provide your email and we'll notify you when the review is ready. Reviews typically take 10–15 minutes.

Email address *

Drag & drop a PDF here, or click to browse

Limits — manuscript & supplementary: up to 50 pages / 30 MB each; code: up to 50 MB (.zip).

Code (.zip) (optional) Supplementary (.pdf) (optional)

Request feedback on a specific section or topic (optional)

By default, the reviewer evaluates the overall paper. If you specify a section or topic, the reviewer will focus its criticism on that part and ensure each item is distinct.

Review Settings

Enable references published after the paper

When enabled, the reviewer uses the latest knowledge including works published after the manuscript. When disabled, only references published before the manuscript date are used (date is auto-detected from the PDF, or you can set it manually below).

Criticize items in the Limitations section

When enabled, the reviewer may criticize items mentioned in the Limitations section if they are not justifiable. When disabled, the reviewer will skip issues already acknowledged by the authors.

Maximum number of review items

Control how many criticism points (1-10) the reviewer generates. Fewer items means only the most significant issues are reported.

Reviewer criteria

Choose a preset criteria set or customize your own. Nature criteria focus on validity and data quality; NeurIPS criteria emphasize originality, technical quality, clarity, and significance.